21 Comments

This is an excellent letter. I have no doubt that Prof. Kayum Ahmed just discarded this letter and ignored it. This is the most common reaction by those in our activist class, who are positive they are correct, in spite of all the evidence. They usually decline to debate the issues, but when they do, all they produce is a torrent of abuse and nonsense.

I have had it with these "social justice" characters. It is long past time to push back on them, in ways that they will understand.

Expand full comment
Apr 7Liked by Alex Turkeltaub

It is a splendid letter. In the same spirit as the letter, may I share my ethnographic approach to the parties in the conflict? This approach takes seriously what the local parties have to say:

https://pjmedia.com/philip-carl-salzman/2024/03/27/what-do-israelis-want-what-do-palestinians-want-n4927679#google_vignette

Expand full comment

Don't you dare bring historical facts and logical reasoning to a football match.

Expand full comment

Great post! But why designating Ashkenazi Jews as "white" and Mizrahi Jews as "brown"? We are all indigenous to the Middle East. Some of us are mixed after many centuries in Europe, but we weren't considered "white" until a few decades ago, when it became convenient to do so.

Expand full comment

Always great to see propaganda confronted and beaten.

Expand full comment

I really like this letter and have posted it around a few accounts on X that are complaining about Columbia Univ. acting wrongly towards this toxic character. It is high time that there was a strong pushback against the simple-minded yet bullying or intransigent people who think they are so virtuous while using completely distorted - and abusive - reasoning. I blame the Left, which now is at its most extreme and we are in danger from it.

Expand full comment